I would ask lee, but I don't want to keep bugging him, and I'll be talking to him next week, so can anyone give me some info. Ill hopefully be going up there some times soon and have a private lesson. Here Im guessing he'll assess me.
But what can I expect from my first combatives class. Private/weekly group.
Thanks!
But what can I expect from my first combatives class. Private/weekly group.
Thanks!
Search results for "What to expect from your first RBSD/combatives class?"
15 Replies
1 Coops, on 24/03/2007 at 18:13
You should expect to walk out of the session with a couple of workable techniques ready to go.
Coops
Coops
2 pmatt, on 24/03/2007 at 19:43
Cool. Any ideas what will happen during it? Ie just showing, focus pads bag work? etc
3 Coops, on 24/03/2007 at 20:22
Hmm. An hour with me would be open hands on the pads, covering incoming blows (sort of a fence) and our double palmed shot to the face.
Within that time you would pick up appropriate posture (stance) and a start to the principles of close contact blows.
Like many others on this list who train people, you would leave the gym being able to hit and cover.
gotta go - grandson has jumped on m\zy1 knee and started puynching keys
Co/op// s
Within that time you would pick up appropriate posture (stance) and a start to the principles of close contact blows.
Like many others on this list who train people, you would leave the gym being able to hit and cover.
gotta go - grandson has jumped on m\zy1 knee and started puynching keys
Co/op// s
4 pmatt, on 24/03/2007 at 20:24
Do you cover open hand strikes, punching, or both?
5 Ade, on 24/03/2007 at 20:28
| Coops wrote: |
| and our double palmed shot to the face.
|
Care to expand on that,gra//nd/ad?
Ade
6 mick s, on 24/03/2007 at 22:21
i would hope you would walk out of the class with the feeling of YES IVE ACTUALLY FOUND WHAT IVE BEEN LOOKING FOR i know i did. mick
7 DaveCollins, on 24/03/2007 at 22:40
| Ade wrote: | ||
Care to expand on that,gra//nd/ad? Ade |
While Grandad sorts himself out, you might find what you're looking for at about half way down this page...
http://www.urbancombatives.com/janws2.htm
If it differs with Coops' approach I'm sure he will elucidate.
8 pmatt, on 24/03/2007 at 23:16
1) Do combatives cover punching aswell as palm strikes?
2)Cover grappling (esp ground fighting )
3) Spar, or practice techniques with non compliance?
2)Cover grappling (esp ground fighting )
3) Spar, or practice techniques with non compliance?
9 Coops, on 25/03/2007 at 18:37
[quote="DaveCollins] While Grandad sorts himself out, you might find what you're looking for at about half way down this page...
http://www.urbancombatives.com/janws2.htm
If it differs with Coops' approach I'm sure he will elucidate.[/quote]
Sorry folks. As you saw, the writing went haywire, then it was bathtime (that time where grandson is supposed to be the only one who gets a soaking, but never is - thank god we have a tiled floor), then bedtime and guess where the computer is - yup, tucked in a corner of his room.
Anyway, back to the strike. The shot of Lee has his hands splayed outwards, although the two shots below don't. Ours is like the two below. There was a time when I was younger when I could get my hands to do what Lee's can, but not now.
Truth is, I think the difference stemms from the origin of the strike. Lee teaches the 'fence' usually with palms up, where as we position our hands with palms half facing the baddie, half facing down. That position means that the two hands don't alter their attitude, they just crash straight in, ending up in the same position as the two photo's under Lee's. Both methods hit hard and fast, it's just the starting position, no big deal.
We don't teach punching, but I have no issues with punchers and punching, exept when someone's doing it to me
We don't do much ground fighting. We kick and bite and tear every so often, but thats not easy to train a lot, as the wife wonders where you've been
Coops
http://www.urbancombatives.com/janws2.htm
If it differs with Coops' approach I'm sure he will elucidate.[/quote]
Sorry folks. As you saw, the writing went haywire, then it was bathtime (that time where grandson is supposed to be the only one who gets a soaking, but never is - thank god we have a tiled floor), then bedtime and guess where the computer is - yup, tucked in a corner of his room.
Anyway, back to the strike. The shot of Lee has his hands splayed outwards, although the two shots below don't. Ours is like the two below. There was a time when I was younger when I could get my hands to do what Lee's can, but not now.
Truth is, I think the difference stemms from the origin of the strike. Lee teaches the 'fence' usually with palms up, where as we position our hands with palms half facing the baddie, half facing down. That position means that the two hands don't alter their attitude, they just crash straight in, ending up in the same position as the two photo's under Lee's. Both methods hit hard and fast, it's just the starting position, no big deal.
We don't teach punching, but I have no issues with punchers and punching, exept when someone's doing it to me
We don't do much ground fighting. We kick and bite and tear every so often, but thats not easy to train a lot, as the wife wonders where you've been
Coops
10 Ade, on 25/03/2007 at 21:34
Thanks for the elucidation Coops
Just to clarify (and i need telling at least a dozen times on most things),when the hands strike are they at about 11-12 o'clock(left) and 12-1 o'clock (right)?
Ade
Just to clarify (and i need telling at least a dozen times on most things),when the hands strike are they at about 11-12 o'clock(left) and 12-1 o'clock (right)?
Ade
11 Coops, on 25/03/2007 at 22:22
| Ade wrote: |
| Thanks for the elucidation Coops Just to clarify (and i need telling at least a dozen times on most things),when the hands strike are they at about 11-12 o'clock(left) and 12-1 o'clock (right)? Ade |
Thay are in the most comfortable position for your skeleton. We are all different.
Coops
12 pmatt, on 25/03/2007 at 22:28
Coops. Would the same not teaching punching/not doing ground fighting count for lee aswell?
Do you do sparring or no compliance practice?
Do you do sparring or no compliance practice?
13 alban, on 26/03/2007 at 12:56
Hi pmatt
i have been training with Lee for the last 3 years. Lee would tell you to train in boxing for body machanics only but not use closed fists
(apart from the hammerfist the only closed hand strike that we use and a good one too) but again he says if thats 's what you do and had succcess with then go with that but there are chances you'll break you hands( i have anyway before i started train with Lee).he would tell you to do grappling to understand the game but not go to the ground, should you go to the ground? get the fuck up on your feet again, but again he teaches grappling as a last resort yes, until you get the chance to get up.
as far as the sparring goes;
there is no sparring in combatives, is not a sport, combatives are something you do to someone or on someone, in other words beat the crap out of him before he does it to you.
there is a lot of scenario work where one is the attacker and the other attacks the attacker, if that makes sense to you.
for more go and train with Lee and you'll see for your self.
he's way of teaching is you learn it at the gym and you'll be able to you use on you way to the car in a car park after training, if you had to of course.
i have been training with Lee for the last 3 years. Lee would tell you to train in boxing for body machanics only but not use closed fists
(apart from the hammerfist the only closed hand strike that we use and a good one too) but again he says if thats 's what you do and had succcess with then go with that but there are chances you'll break you hands( i have anyway before i started train with Lee).he would tell you to do grappling to understand the game but not go to the ground, should you go to the ground? get the fuck up on your feet again, but again he teaches grappling as a last resort yes, until you get the chance to get up.
as far as the sparring goes;
there is no sparring in combatives, is not a sport, combatives are something you do to someone or on someone, in other words beat the crap out of him before he does it to you.
there is a lot of scenario work where one is the attacker and the other attacks the attacker, if that makes sense to you.
for more go and train with Lee and you'll see for your self.
he's way of teaching is you learn it at the gym and you'll be able to you use on you way to the car in a car park after training, if you had to of course.
14 Socrates, on 26/03/2007 at 13:47
Pmatt:
You don´t have to restrict yourself to one style / teacher. Nick Hughes, a US-based instructor with a Q&A on this site, always says that it's best to get a black belt (or equivalent) in one core style and then go and do lots of cross-training. This is excellent advice, because no style is (or can ever be) complete.
For example, you might want to train with Lee Morrison for a few years to get the whole self-defence thing under control. In a few year's time, though, you might want to join a sports grappling club (health issues permitting). You never know, you might end up doing something completely different in your 30s...
All the best,
S
You don´t have to restrict yourself to one style / teacher. Nick Hughes, a US-based instructor with a Q&A on this site, always says that it's best to get a black belt (or equivalent) in one core style and then go and do lots of cross-training. This is excellent advice, because no style is (or can ever be) complete.
For example, you might want to train with Lee Morrison for a few years to get the whole self-defence thing under control. In a few year's time, though, you might want to join a sports grappling club (health issues permitting). You never know, you might end up doing something completely different in your 30s...
All the best,
S
15 pmatt, on 26/03/2007 at 17:27
Cheers for the confirmation guys!
Replies 1 to 15 on 15 for "What to expect from your first RBSD/combatives class?"
Hey guys,
In a discussion with Rich Demitri he stated that he doesn't teach combatives but more RBSD/P. Having studied Combatives for a little time now and trained under Lee M it is obvious to me that you can't really get any closer to reality than what
What do you think about the mixing training of RBSD with sport fighting (like Boxing, Muay Thai,..)? Sport fighting is yes limited by roules but gives you a good conditioning. In other way in gives you a false attitude.
Or is better to do only RBSD
From here...
http://www.bullshido.net/forums/showthread.php?t=18955&page=2
It's an old article, but has some good points for discussion I feel.
PART 1 Any visitor to Bullshido will soon notice that Reality Based Self Defense training does






